I read the article and dismissed most of it. I, too, put a lot of faith in their research, but try to remember who they and and why they exist. [They've come up with beaucoup egg of their faces a few times, too.]
To me, the review of ALL the trucks was written from the perspective of somebody that drives cars and has to practical use for a pickup, let alone a one ton. If you never tow or haul anything, get off in the deep sticks or such, then their review is right on. Why buy a truck then?
I try to imagine a review of the Honda Fit or Kia Cinco written by the guys at, for instance, Truck Trend magazine. It would be about as weird. :shades: