I think that MT is just exhibiting the same slant that Car and Driver and Consumer Reports do...
AMERICAN manufacturers = BAD
FOREIGN manufacturers (particularly Honda) = GREAT
I remember receiving a SPECIAL EDITION of C&D extolling the wonderous virtues of the Audi TT. I sat in the thing at a car show and wondered what car C&D had reviewed... cramped, uninviting interior, wretched driving position and controls, and horrifying sticker price.
It has also gotten to the point that I can't even look at my Consumer Reports auto review section anymore... they will literally stop at nothing to bash the hell out of EVERY domestic car/truck and throw in some of the most pathetic little digs at the car, all the while singing the hosannas of (enter import name here) no matter how crappy the car really is.
The Ridgeline is a worthless excuse for a "truck" and has a stupefying price - this is the reason for its pathetic sales. Only a biased reporter (or one on the take) could possibly prefer it to worthy trucks from Ford, Chevy, or Dodge.