I have the 2011 Edge SE FWD with 18" wheels and Michelin tires. We took it to Maine for Christmas and negotiated through at least 6" of unplowed snow with no problem. I am averaging around 22 MPG with normal driving, slightly higher on the highway. While I have ridden around in the 2011 Explorer, I haven't really had a chance to drive it for any length of time, but initial reports from customers is that they love it. As NickF1011 said, the two vehicles are very similar so it comes down to what you need in a vehicle.