If someone asked 5 years ago if there was an American car at the top of its class I wouldn't have any to point to. There are so many quality/safe/reliable/fast/affordable American cars on the market today it is hard to take the Pilot's comment seriously. If you want to spend $42,000 on a BMW 335i coupe /w only 300hp and 26mpg good for you, but for most people who want to spend $20-$30,000 they can get a Ford Mustang /w 315hp and 30mpg. You're paying a lot of $$$$ for worse performance and efficiency of a supposed superior vehicle.
World Class American cars
-Cadillac CTS-V (It beat the MB E-class AMG for $40,000 less!)
-Corvette ZR-1 (Fastest production vehicle on nurburgring)
-Ford F-150 Raptor (80mph in the desert / Competes in the Baja 1000 / $38,000 (less then a Tundra LTD)
-GMC Sierra
-Ford Mustang GT500 (Most affordable $/Hp and soon to outrun an M3 on a track)
-Ford Fusion Hybrid/Mercury Milan Hybrid (41mpg (better then VW's TDI system) / Durability & quality levels unsurpassed by Toyota / Motor trend car of the year)
-Ford Fiesta ( 40mpg / affordable price / class-leading handling / one of the best selling vehicles world wide )
-Lincoln MKT (365hp and 23mpg better MPG then a BMW 550i / automated parking / adaptive cruise control /refrigerator / collision warning and braking support / MyKey / Sync )
-Ford Ka
My next car is a Cadillac CTS-V and for $65,000 /w 550hp I can't get a better car for the money.
BMW M5 500hp $85,500
MB E-class AMG 518hp $85,750
Audi S6 435hp $76,100
Lexus IS-F 416hp $57,600